|Nadia Bloom is carried out of swamp by a Winter Springs Police Officer|
©Winter Springs Police
I oppose these expansions to the Alzheimer's protection bill because I see it as building a foundation to monitor and criminalize autistic children of color without physical incarceration. It is too much like pushing the culture of the ankle restraints and GPS tracking initiatives that is the latest morphing of the mass incarceration system, and our nonprofits are lobbying for the funding to support and promote it in the name of gaining police training funding for their organizations to aid in "protection from wandering."
This is terrifying.
Let's look at two cases of wandering and analyze the wide scope of an ill-defined legislative action and where my concerns lie.
1. The Case of Nadia Bloom
Nadia Bloom, an 11-year-old who for some reason news organizations put the Aspergers label on rather than stating she was autistic, watched her father and sister leave for a camping trip to the Everglades with her sister's Brownie troop. She was excluded from such a trip. Carrying a book called "Lanie" about an adventurous girl who loves the outdoors, Nadia sets off into the alligator-ridden swamp and gets lost. A frantic search for her ensues. Four days later she is found by a neighbor who attended her parent's church, covered in mosquito bites but otherwise alright. Nadia later stated she got caught up in the wildlife and lost track of landmarks and time.
|Paramedic Hollis Lipscomb tends to autistic hiker, |
18-year-old Jacob Allen, after he was found
Thursday, Oct. 18, 2007, in the Dolly Sods Wilderness Area
near Davis, W.Va. where he went missing four days ago. © AP
Jacob Allen was an 18-year-old nonspeaking autistic student whose brother took him for regular wilderness hikes to calm him from an otherwise very restrictive school life. Jacob also regularly camped and hiked with his family. He knew the woods and he had basic survival skills despite being nonspeaking, and despite being labeled a disabled person with a "mental age of a 3 or 4 year old." Per local West Virginia newspapers:
"Mr. Allen, of Morgantown, wandered away from his parents during a Sunday afternoon hike in the Dolly Sods Wilderness Area. "
Per CBS news: "After four cold days and four nearly freezing nights, searchers spotted the 18-year-old sleeping under a thicket of laurel in the Dolly Sods Wilderness Area, part of the Monongahela National Forest."
"It made sort of like an umbrella, but underneath it was bare and open," State Police 1st Sgt. Jim Wise said. "It made some type of shelter."
"Though Allen was less than a mile from the spot where searchers had found his hat Monday, the brush kept his location hidden until Thursday afternoon. Wise believes it also may have kept the teen, who is nonverbal, from wandering toward 20- to 30-foot cliffs."
"He rolled over after I called his name and he didn't have much in the way of reaction, but he recognized me. I could tell," said Jeremy Reneau, 25, the first to spot Allen. "
Throughout this ordeal, Jacob Allen's brother expressed incredible faith in him. He kept repeating that Jacob knew the woods and knew how to survive in them. No one listened. After Jacob was found, the story became one of an excuse to justify tracking devices. What happened next was Jacob, who survived 4 days in freezing temperatures by knowing what to do, was fitted with an ankle bracelet. Here is a photo of the device being installed on Jacob Allen:
Here is a photograph of an ankle monitor, tether or ankle bracelet used to monitor criminal offenders when under house arrest or on parole:
|Corrections officer installing ankle bracelet on inmate|
The devices are the same and serve the same purpose. So Mr. Allen is under permanent house arrest and monitoring for the crime of walking too far ahead and becoming disoriented and lost.
No one wonders why he "elopes." This is their solution.
Spoiler alert: Boxing Helena was in the end a perverse dream of a surgeon about his neighbor. Acting to restrict any individual without understanding why he feels the need to wander and without his consent is inhumane.
Our nonprofits are all okay with doing this to any autistic child or adult unable to give consent. And we are all okay with that?
I remember being young. Going where I was not supposed to go to test my boundaries and test my limits at the behest of friends who didn't have much better sense than I did. I've also lost myself on forest trails but have been fortunate enough to have the basic knowledge to find my way out again. My mother lost my sister and I when I was a toddler during the press of a crowd at JFK. When she found us no one suggested she shackle us together to keep better tabs on us.
The term Wanderlust was created to define the human need to wander and explore. Entire peoples based lifestyles on nomadic life and some continue to do so today. So wandering is an instinct in us. I think wandering isn't the issue but how to ensure safety of those who do and how to understand this need is the issue and we are not addressing that. The zeal to embrace a cycle of police centered training and monitoring and restricting movements of our people as a solution among autism organizations with disregard for the consent of those who will be forced to endure it all is not only ableism in legislative advocacy, it is ethically and morally bankrupt as a solution to protecting children and nonspeaking autistic adults if they do not or cannot proactively consent to such measures.
Now let's talk about how effective these tracking devices are:
For autistic children:
Missing autistic girl, 10, found dead after her wrist tracking device failed to send a signal http://bit.ly/jtSvXM
For convicted felons:
Convicted White Supremacist Evan Ebel killed Colorado prison director after his ankle monitor failed:
Any action that places disabled individuals under surveillance without their consent and restricts their movements is a violation of their human rights and tantamount to incarceration. Police have been trained, this did not stop an officer in Florida from aiming for nonspeaking autistic citizen Arnaldo Rios Soto and shooting his support aide. Clearly acquiring even more funding to train them is not going to solve that problem either.
Funding these types of measures are not a solution. Boxing wanderlust will destroy those people we are trying to protect to supposed solve the wandering issue. Funding that could be used for more humane protections and patient centered research into the nature of wandering being used to do this is variant of shackling is wrong.
I am against these measures without the consent of those they purport to be for, and to my knowledge no one autistic has been asked to consult or discuss the impact on autistic individuals of Avonte's Law. It is an abomination to me that the name of an African American autistic teen be placed on a bill to fund shackling autistic youth and nonspeaking adults.
Although it doesn't seem like serious things may go down soon, the waters are pretty murky. Stay vigilant.ReplyDelete
I would have used. Yes, it's not 100% but quickest fix for what could be a serious problem. Most wanderlust ventures end safely, but any person who is at risk of not being able to care from self during such jaunts is at high risk of more acute dangers and death even. Agree community awareness and integration is key but isn't there and will take time. The monitor is here. For those at very high risk to wander off, it can reduce risk of serious consequencesReplyDelete
Had neighbor with Down syndrome son that wandered away regularly. Neighbors and community all in unison when happened. He was picked up by someone and left off miles away. No idea if any harm done. Family tight lipped and kid did not wander off again with draconian measures taken with house locks after that. If he had been found before pick up, perhaps would not have happened. An alert if kid left premises or yard. It's a chance. But that these monitors are available it's up to caregivers to decide to get and use. Don't have to get if Dont want
As aside, parents of teens, young adults using GPS function of cellphones and cars to track their movements.